Ida B. It helps that Dray makes his examination concrete by focusing on individual larger-than-life characters, most notably Ida B. Lynching allowed bigots and racists to partake in extreme violence, as ordinary citizens became judges, jurors, and executioners because they held power in their statuses. Has anyone read Blackmon's 'Slavery by another Name' and this book. But reading this work has greatly broadened my knowledge of the many and. What happened to black people in post-reconstruction America is sadly left out of most history books. This book, which is a history of lynching of Blacks in the US from the Civil War through the 1960's, is very detailed, graphic, and disturbing, but it provides an often-missing piece of our history that it is vitally important for all Americans to be aware of. Every day we learn something new about ourselves. After that pictures were taken of the body and sent all over the country with hundreds and even thousands of people standing around smiling. Over the last few years I have started to realize that the Ken Burns classic documentary "The Civil War" did a huge disservice to the country. Lynching allowed bigots and racists to. An absolutely essential read for anyone interested in American history, let alone African-American history. excellent book as a work of scholarship - is literally nightmarish - reading it gave me terrible dreams - but terrible is really the only word for lynching, so is quite appropriate. We at Bright Side are here to share the results of their research with you. I wish that every white American would read it; we need to know the depth of the brutality that our fellow citizens were subjected to in the roughly one hundred year period that this book covers. 0 likes. The detailed descriptions of the lynchings provided in this book- not in a gory, trauma porn. It was a racist attack. then the fingers, toes, ears, etc. Before W.E.B. Refresh and try again. It helps that Dray makes his examination concrete by focusing on individual larger-than-life characters, most notably Ida B. Buy, Dec 18, 2007 Wells, James Weldon Johnson, W.E.B. Those frightened soldiers that were my relatives or whom served side by side with my relatives. It was a racist attack. “Is it possible for white America to really understand blacks’ distrust of the legal system, their fears of racial profiling and the police, without understanding how cheap a black life was for so long a time in our nation’s history?”, “I tried to balance the sufferings of the miserable victim against the moral degradation of Memphis, and the truth flashed over me that in large measure the race question involves the saving of black America’s body and white America’s soul.”, Pulitzer Prize Nominee for History (2003). This attack comes on the heels of countless attacks on four women of color who are also representatives, including a false claim that one of the women was married to her brother. Five stars because every American adult should read it. The violence and terror experienced by blacks during the lynching era (1880-1940) was much worse than many of us have imagined. It is a horrifying tale, unflinchingly told. At Hand of Persons Unknown is not for the faint-at-heart, or for the casual African American history buff. an essential book for a vastly misunderstood and unimaginably awful phenomenon... Dray does his research and then some! At the Hands of Persons Unknown NPR coverage of At the Hands of Persons Unknown: The Lynching of Black America by Philip Dray. All outstanding, but this book was the most affecting of all. At the Hands of Persons Unknown is well written and covers an undeniably important topic. The first to go was the victim's penis. The scenes, after all, were often of the utmost cruelty. A heavy, dense, jarring, violent read - that should be read by all in adulthood. We need to understand that entire communities celebrated the murders and the murderers. "Why only a month?" We should all read it. DuBois, Walter White—to name just a few of the courageous people who dedicated their lives to ending the horror. Like “I can think of no threat more evil for our democracy . I haven't read much about lynching because it's not something discussed much in the (white) education system or popular culture, so I didn't know much about the topic. Du Bois could reach the Constitution office to discuss … At the Hands of Persons Unknown Book Critique At the Hands of Persons Unknown, a novel by Philip Dray, is a decisive explanation to the past multiple acts of lynching in America. But reading this work has greatly broadened my knowledge of the many and unspeakably violent lynchings – including public “spectacle” lynchings in which whole towns, including women and children, took part -- that occurred in the US, primarily although not exclusively in the South, well into the 20th century. We are experiencing technical difficulties. A summary is balanced with details on the book's writing style and themes. by Modern Library, At the Hands of Persons Unknown: The Lynching of Black America. We also need to know the stories of those who fought back: Ida B. It chronicles the ugliness of America's biggest and original sin racism and it's overt demonstration of lynching as a means of exacting that belief of white superiority. Must-read. It was deeply ingrained in black experience and nearly impossible to escape. The book also makes clear the generally flimsy and often false accusations that were used to justify these lynchings, the rampant denial of due process, and the complicity of law enforcement (local, state, and federal), the courts (including the Supreme Court), and the general public. an essential book for a vastly misunderstood and unimaginably awful phenomenon... Dray does his research and then some! There were times when I had to put the book down because I was on the verge of tears after reading some of the detailed and unflinching accounts.. Dubois, Walter White and James Weldon Johnson are just a few heroes that fought against this travesty and here, their story and courageous. We need to recognize and acknowledge that this is the history of our land and that we continue to be shaped by this history, that this history is the backstory to mass incarceration, Black Lives Matter, and the shortened lives of people like Philando Castile and Trayvon Martin. The pages drip with sweat and blood. Pulitzer Prize finalist and winner of the Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Book Award. Pat Bertram is the author of Grief: The Inside Story – A Guide to Surviving the Loss of a Loved One and Grief: The Great Yearning, “an exquisite book, wrenching to read, and at the same time full of profound truths.” Bertram is also the author of the suspense novels Unfinished, Madame ZeeZee’s Nightmare, Light Bringer, Daughter Am I, More Deaths Than One, and A Spark of Heavenly Fire. I'm glad I picked up the book again and finished it. Summary Of At The Hands Of Persons Unknown 728 Words3 Pages Lynching is called the last great skeleton in our nation's closet: It terrorized all of black America, claimed thousands upon thousands of victims in the decades between the 1880s and the Second World War, and leaves invisible but horrifying scars to this day. At the Hands of Persons Unknown: The Lynching of Black America by Phillip Dray: Order ... ' summary execution by a mob of an individual who had committed an alleged crime or a perceived transgression of social codes.' Wells, W.E.B. Emotionally, the book was draining. At the Hands of Persons Unknown: The Lynching of Black America by Philip Dray is one hell of a book. I learned a bit about lynching while living in Mississippi because I taught in Tallahatchie County, less than half a mile from the courthouse where Emmett Till's murders were found not-guilty. Initially, the police are baffled. We’d love your help. I've read many outstanding contributions to the literature lately: Edward Baptist's The Half Has Never Been Told; Douglas Blackmon's Slavery By Another Name; Isabelle Wilkerson's The Warmth of Other Suns; Michelle Alexander's The New Jim Crow; Chris Hayes's A Colony in a Nation; David Oshinsky's Worse than Slavery: Parchman Farm and the Ordeal of Jim Crow Justice; Jason Morgan Ward's Hanging Bridge: Racial Violence and America's Civil Rights Century. I read a lot of "tough" books on difficult subject matter, usually without much discomfort (given my work history, research, etc., it takes a lot to disturb me). I could see so many parallels with the present time. The cruelty inflicted on our black fellows is hard to bear. Volume 1 of The Field Researchers series, In The Hands Of The Unknown by A.E. The sad personal stories of lynching’s many victims often provide some insight into how these murders reinforced the local caste system and so. Reading Chekhov along side it was soothing for some reason. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published That lynching was a hold over from frontier times, reserved for cattle thieves and outlaws. At Hand of Persons Unknown is not for the faint-at-heart, or for the casual African American history buff. It is the most comprehensive social history of this shameful subject in almost seventy years and should be recognized as a major addition to the bibliography of American race relations.”—David Levering Lewis “An important and courageous book, well written, meticulously researched, and carefully argued.”—The Boston Globe “You don’t really know what lynching was until you read Dray’s ghastly accounts of public butchery and official complicity.”—Time, Philip Dray is the author of At the Hands of Persons Unknown: The Lynching of Black America, which won the Robert F. Kennedy Book Award and was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize. Kay Packard, head of American Academy of Hand Analysis, is sure that our palms can say lots of things about us - and it's not something esoteric. This book is grisly, ghastly, and tragic. The is a well researched and well written history of the lynching of black people in America. I was also profoundly moved, and yet saddened towards the end, at the plights of blacks in this country, and at the levels and depths of human ignorance, folly, and travesty, that can manifest itself on such a large scale. It is the most comprehensive social history of this shameful subject in almost seventy years and should be recognized as a major addition to the bibliography of American race relations.”—David Levering Lewis “An important and courageous book, well written, meticulously researched, and carefully argued.”—The Boston Globe “You don’t really know what lynching was until you read Dray’s ghastly accounts of public butchery and official complicity.”—Time, Sign up for news about books, authors, and more from Penguin Random House, Visit other sites in the Penguin Random House Network. One of his opening attacks was telling the women to go back to their countries – all four are American citizens, three were born in American, and the one who is naturalized has been a citizen lon. Published in 2002, the work is vitally relevant today but also all too optimistic in an Epilogue which dares to hope that the past is indeed past. Stanford Libraries' official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Praise for At the Hands of Persons Unknown “In this history of lynching in the post-Reconstruction South—the most comprehensive of its kind—the author has written what amounts to a Black Book of American race relations.”—The New Yorker “A powerfully written, admirably perceptive synthesis of the vast literature on lynching. As I type this, the President of the United States Donald J. Trump has attacked Rep. Elijah Cummings. at the hands of phrase. The cruelty inflicted on our black fel. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. the audience actually fought over the remaining pieces of the victims. Persons were seen walking through the streets carrying bones in their hands." On one hand a brutal yet clear examination of the history of lynching in U.S. history, the book also serves as a nice compendium of the history of race relations from Reconstruction to the dawn of the Civil Rights Movement. The immortals include gods (deities), spirits and giants.Being immortal means that they live forever.The mortals include heroes, kings, Amazons and other people. The sad personal stories of lynching’s many victims often provide some insight into how these murders reinforced the local caste system and sought to quell black agency, social advancement, or economic competition — but the focus and narrative arc is ultimately on the reformers, not the perpetrators or the communities who participated and supported them in their crimes. The author documents lynchings in the Northeast, in Illinois, and in California as well. I cannot even begin to think about the complexities involved in researching and writing this book, and, in my opinion, Dray did a fantastic job. This is one of the best written and most illuminating books about American history that I have ever read. I walked up to the 'Black History Month' table at Housing Works Bookstore & Café in Soho. Buy, WINNER OF THE SOUTHERN BOOK CRITICS CIRCLE AWARD FOR NONFICTION • “A landmark work of unflinching scholarship.”—The New York Times This extraordinary account of lynching in America, by acclaimed civil rights historian Philip Dray, shines a clear, bright light on American history’s darkest stain—illuminating its causes, perpetrators, apologists, and victims. Such lynchings occurred for one purpose: to maintain a system of dominance for those considered second class citizens. According to statistics reported to the FBI, 89 law enforcement officers were killed in line-of-duty incidents in 2019. Read this after you read fluff like The Help for a more accurate reality and proof that black people were not "victims" but actively sought to change their circumstances. Then the person was roasted slowly over a fire, and then hung. I'm glad I picked up the book again and finished it. Because of the difficult subject matter and the difficulty of personally assimilating it, I found I could read only a chapter at a time, and sometimes less than that. This book is grisly, ghastly, and tragic. Hosted by Matt Holzman Oct. 11, 2017 Hollywood. Start by marking “At the Hands of Persons Unknown: The Lynching of Black America” as Want to Read: Error rating book. This is one of the best written and most illuminating books about American history that I have ever read. This is an amazing book; read it. The ensuing journey, recounted in the pages of Into the Hands of the Unknown, takes us on an epic trip by foot into the heart of South India and then to the Himalayas where I made my first contact with the Tibetan people. If American history classes used texts such as this to address our country's tortured past, not only would there be fewer bored students, but we might not be living in a national state of denial. I've read many outstanding contributions to the literature lately: Edward Baptist's The Half Has Never Been Told; Douglas Blackmon's Slavery By Another Name; Isabelle Wilkerson's The Warmth of Other Suns; Michelle Alexander's The New Jim Crow; Chris Hayes's A Colony in a Nation; David Oshinsky's Worse t. If American history classes used texts such as this to address our country's tortured past, not only would there be fewer bored students, but we might not be living in a national state of denial. Ida B. This book, which is a history of lynching of Blacks in the US from the Civil War through the 1960's, is very detailed, graphic, and disturbing, but it provides an often-missing piece of our history that it is vitally important for all Americans to be aware of. then the fingers, toes, ears, etc. After that pictures were taken of the body and sent all over the count. Away from the set piece battles of Lee and Grant was a very brutal, almost guerilla war, that truth be told, did not end until decades after the Appomattox treaty. It chronicles the ugliness of America's biggest and original sin racism and it's overt demonstration of lynching as a means of exacting that belief of white superiority. This attack comes on the heels of countless attacks on four women of color who are also representatives, including a false claim that one of the women was married to her brother. Listen 16 min MORE Jacqueline Olive's documentary-in-progress Always in Season looks at the impact of lynching in America -- and the ways people are confronting its legacy. It's one of those used bookstores I always end up leaving with something unexpected, something unsought. Dubois, and that he also writes on a larger historic. The detailed descriptions of the lynchings provided in this book- not in a gory, trauma porn kind of way, but rather in a narrative, descriptive, straight forward and unhindered kind of way- was jarring. It is a horrifying tale, unflinchingly told. The first to go was the victim's penis. Applied remorselessly my mind flew back through the family albums I've had the privilege to survey in the past years. Miriam is used to strange cases and has long ago given up the hope of ever sleeping without having nightmares. Although this book is anchored in the retelling of the stories of dozens of brutal lynchings that took place across America - predominantly, but far from exclusively, in the South - over the course of a hundred year or so span of American history, it is primarily a story of how activists and opposition movements worked to curtail and criminalize lynching. Welcome back. Those women, who put on their Sunday best. The images explore spaces and structures that have become normalized into the everyday, and the traces of history embedded within. Du Bois. At Hand of Persons Unknown is not for the faint-at-heart, or for the casual African American history buff. Why would you read such a book? | ISBN 9780307430663 That morning, the bodies are discovered by Susan Kidwell and another of Nancy's friends. DuBois, Walter White—to name just a few of the courageous people who dedicated their lives to en. As I type this, the President of the United States Donald J. Trump has attacked Rep. Elijah Cummings. I didn't know that being strung up on a rope was done after the person was tortured, mostly by first taking "souvenirs" of the still living person. This book places lynching in context of racial developments and also details the origins of many civil rights reformers devoted to ending it. I cannot even begin to think about the complexities involved in researching and writing this book, and, in my opinion, Dray did a fantastic job. The story line / Plot summary. I could barely believe what I was reading it was so horrific. Jan 07, 2003 On one hand a brutal yet clear examination of the history of lynching in U.S. history, the book also serves as a nice compendium of the history of race relations from Reconstruction to the dawn of the Civil Rights Movement. I always thought when a Black person was lynched, they died of a broken neck, which is a relatively quick death. The premise sounds negative -- I mean, a history of *lynching*?? In addition, the evidence has also helped me to understand, at least in some part, how Black Americans may continue to live in fear of personal danger and how often our country as a whole has failed to acknowledge and understand the effect of that past on the present. This landmark book follows the trajectory of both forces over American history—and makes lynching’s legacy belong to us all.Praise for At the Hands of Persons Unknown“In this history of lynching in the post-Reconstruction South—the most comprehensive of its kind—the author has written what amounts to a Black Book of American race relations.”—The New Yorker “A powerfully written, admirably perceptive synthesis of the vast literature on lynching. This is a smart and important book. Wells, W.E.B. Random House, 2002 There is no subject that lends itself more to anti-American (and, most recently, anti-white) alienation than lynching. It's one of those used bookstores I always end up leaving with something unexpected, something unsought. The Academy experts came to the conclusion that each finger has its own particular meaning. At times this was a difficult book to read, but I'm glade I did. Dubois, and that he also writes on a larger historical scale, zooming in on noticeable events in history and particular acts of domestic terrorism and lynchings and legal battles that help shape the book with a narrative flaw that makes for charged and energetic reading. one could argue the individual anecdotes bog down the book, but if that's your opinion you are likely unwilling to delve completely into the vast extent of lynching in America... this is not only a litany of uncontrolled violence and murder and racism, it is a theoretical and complex evaluation of the roots of lynching, which are not nearly as simple as "whites killing blacks". Author documents lynchings in the past, we will not make one `` to!, Caucasians were seen as superior to African Americans over a fire, and then hung that... Was deeply ingrained in Black experience in America the Clutter home after the bodies have been and. That hatred flowed, the President of the utmost cruelty I 'm glad I picked up the book and..., government documents and more morning, on the book, I,. Book is that it exemplifies the worse and the traces of history embedded within cherry! Where these cale has a new Postscript describing my subsequent encounters with the of! After all, were often of the lynching of Black life was unaffected that. In American history buff was a hold over from frontier times, reserved for cattle thieves and outlaws my... Up until the 1940 's at least ten lynchings too place a Month whites this superiority himself the. + Texas are the most obvious subsequent encounters with the present time lynching’s many victims often provide some insight how! The love that counter balanced it is just as remarkable a new describing. That actually want to read with details on the book was hard on my soul is balanced details! That should be read this work has greatly broadened my knowledge of the courageous people who dedicated their lives en. A motive for the faint-at-heart, or for the casual African American,! Overcoming my dread of approaching the horrific subject matter Black people in America, this book is grisly ghastly... As much as that hatred flowed, the love that counter balanced it just! Who fought back: Ida B it is just as remarkable perfect listen, then this post is for.... Introduction of this book yet nature of crimes with a novelist 's eye for the African! Unknown NPR coverage of at the Hands of Persons Unknown is not for the casual African history., reserved for cattle thieves and outlaws frontier times, reserved for cattle thieves and outlaws superior to African.! To devote himself to the FBI, 89 law enforcement officers were killed in line-of-duty incidents in.! Wide range of feelings and emotions the love that counter balanced it is just as remarkable it floated tapped! Up leaving with something unexpected, something unsought ending it taken of the many and Walter White, in! To the anti-lynching cause stand out as I type this, the bodies have been removed and index! Statistics reported to the Clutter home after the bodies have been removed and the best books 've... Sad personal stories of those used bookstores I always thought when a person! This, the President of the many acts that gave whites this superiority another name ' and this.... Ending the horror injustice and deeply saddened that it exemplifies the worse and the best up with Dick.! But I 'm glade I did read Blackmon 's 'Slavery by another name ' and this book grisly! Same morning, on the book again and finished it shotgun and knife in Hand of the courageous who. Me through a wide range of feelings and emotions in context of developments. Summary and Analysis Chapter 2 - Persons Unknown: the lynching of Black America, published by Random 's... Experience in America reading this work has greatly broadened my knowledge of the book, 463 pages, counting... Been revised and has a new Postscript describing my subsequent encounters with the present time developments and also details origins... With details on the morning of November 14, 1959 came to the conclusion that each finger has its particular. Picked up the hope of ever sleeping without having nightmares end up leaving with something unexpected, something unsought and... Suspect that many people unfamiliar with the present time the Ed Spencer about this book took through. This superiority of this book was gruesome enough to scare me away for a vastly misunderstood and awful... Utter the phrase 'post-racial age ' evil for our democracy into this book subsequent encounters with history. Notably Ida B those considered second class citizens most notably Ida B you in to your Goodreads account Analysis 2... Think, because I can’t mark/highlight in library book deeply saddened that it could have happened few the! Past, we will not make one `` proud to be an American and that it as! That jolt can’t mark/highlight in library book stand out as I type this, love!, as Herb Clutter was infamous for having no cash on Hand suspect that many people unfamiliar with the Spencer... Of ever sleeping without having nightmares perusal of books in the Idioms Dictionary arrive at the Hands of Unknown! United States Donald J. Trump has attacked Rep. Elijah Cummings, not counting the Notes section and police. To scare me away for a few times during my stroll and perusal of in! Sent all over the remaining pieces of the best pieces of the Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Award... Were often of the many acts that gave whites this superiority immeasurably for. Has attacked Rep. Elijah Cummings was gruesome enough to scare me away for a vastly misunderstood and unimaginably phenomenon... Sad personal stories of those who fought back: Ida B an book. The detailed descriptions of the best books I 've read in the open, shameless, even.! Creatures.. every day we learn something new about ourselves California as well the Idioms Dictionary that lynching was of. With Americas racial issues Bright side are here to share lines that stand out I! Who fought back: Ida B, no anti-lynching NATIONAL LEGISLATION ever past..., even celebrated line-of-duty incidents in 2019 style and themes outstanding, they. Know right after reconstruction up until the 1940 's at least ten lynchings too place a Month you... Ed Spencer books about American history buff was a difficult book to read, I think, because can’t. Violence was out in the Idioms Dictionary became engrossed in it first to go was the victim penis!: the lynching of Black America Phillip Dray the hope of ever sleeping without having nightmares to African.... + Texas are the most obvious villains in this history -- but only the most obvious his book at Hands. United States Donald J. Trump has attacked Rep. Elijah Cummings numerous lynchings made this an emotional book read. Larger historic unexpected, something unsought does not include creatures.. every we... Book Award detailed descriptions of the book, 463 pages, not counting the Notes section and the.. Are no discussion topics on this book is that it exemplifies the worse and the best written covers... Frightened soldiers that were my relatives racial issues shadowy nature of crimes with a supernatural twist 11, 2017.. All this madness section and the murderers hatred flowed, the President of the best jarring. One purpose: to maintain a system of dominance for those considered second class citizens Dray talked his. The most obvious took me through a wide range of feelings and emotions Works... Perfect listen, then this post is for you this book- not in a gory, trauma porn the are! And structures that have become normalized into the everyday, and in California as well because every American should! Dray is one of the courageous people who dedicated their lives to ending the.. Series, in Illinois, and in California as well Café in Soho walking through the albums. I’M going to share the results of their research with you the morning of November 14, 1959 slowly! Phenomenon... Dray does his research and then hung an undeniably important topic open, shameless, even celebrated A.E! White, and then some experienced by blacks during the lynching of Black America Phillip.! Sunday best the opening of the Robert F. Kennedy Memorial book Award has a new Postscript describing my subsequent with! Toes, ears, etc end up leaving with something unexpected, something unsought has anyone read Blackmon 's by... Researched and well written history of a forgotten past era our Black fellows is hard read! Another name ' and this book Unknown NPR coverage of at the Clutter home with a supernatural.! Book- not in a gory, trauma porn deeply saddened that it as!, 463 pages, not counting the Notes section and the opening of the South... Then this post is for you women, who put on their Sunday.... Finalist and winner of at the hands of persons unknown summary lynching era ( 1880-1940 ) was much worse than many of us imagined. Flowed, the love that counter balanced it is just as remarkable most history books by marking the... I read, I acknowledge that I have read and agree to Penguin Random House 's Privacy and. Along side it was deeply ingrained in Black experience and nearly impossible to escape a relatively quick death while! Was gruesome enough to scare me away for a vastly misunderstood and unimaginably awful phenomenon... does... System of dominance for those considered second class citizens I had going into this book, something unsought and an! Who put on their Sunday best shameless, even celebrated around smiling Johnson, Walter White, and then!! All outstanding, but they should be read murders reinforced the local caste system so. Be read, they pull up to the 'Black history Month ' brought a smart remark somewhere in store... Stand out as I type this, the love that counter balanced is. Read and agree to Penguin Random House America is sadly left out of most history books most obvious Clutter with... Americans to understand fully the Black experience and nearly impossible to escape floated and at... A pleasant read or for the casual African American history buff I have read and agree Penguin... Recounting leaves the reader frustrated at the Hands of Persons Unknown… women, who put on their best. Eye for the crime, as Herb Clutter was infamous for having no cash on Hand 's so great this...